Assignment: Evaluation Article critique.
Read the evaluation article for your theme (item 4 on the theme reading list).
Write an article critque in essay form. Some things you will want to do are:
- Describe the goal of the intervention that was evaluated.
- Explain why the researchers and/or practioners thought that the intervention
would or would not be successful.
- Summarize the results of the evaluation. Did the intervention work? (The
answer to this may be complex).
- Describe the type of evaluation design, such as experiment, quasi-experiment,
single-system, or action research; summative or process; qualitative or quantitative.
What research methods were used?
- Describe the stakeholders in the project (the people and organizations that
have a "stake" or investment in the results of the evaluation).
- Summarize what you see as the strengths and weaknesses of the evaluation
(not the intervention). Make sure that you consider issues of internal
and external validity, sampling and generalizability.
- If you ran a school, agency or other organization for which it was appropriate
would you try this intervention? Why or why not? What was your opinion of
the intervention? How, if at all, would you change the program and/or the
evaluation.
As always, this should be in essay format and carefully proof read.